Why it matters for reading Scripture
How each doctrine developed, through the creeds and confessions that fixed it.
Historical theologyHow did belief develop?
History of doctrine is the study of when each Christian doctrine was defined, by whom and in which text, from the rule of faith to the agreements of today, and of which churches hold each definition now. It took shape in German Protestant scholarship as the history of dogma; English-speaking scholars came to prefer the name history of doctrine.
Study v1.1, 30 October 2026
How each doctrine developed, through the creeds and confessions that fixed it.
Most churches confess the faith of Nicaea but receive two, three, seven or twenty-one councils, and fix their teaching in different texts: creeds, definitions, confessions, catechisms or statements of belief.
They divide on Chalcedon and the Filioque, on whether councils or Scripture alone bind, on how doctrine develops, and on whether a church should confess creeds at all.
Receives two councils, Nicaea and Constantinople I, and received the creed and canons of Nicaea at a synod held at Seleucia-Ctesiphon in 410 under Catholicos Isaac.
In Sebastian Brock's account of its synods, the Council of Ephesus (431) is specifically rejected. The church states its Christology in its own East Syriac terms, two qnome in one parsopa, and rejects the label "Nestorian" applied to it by others.
The Coptic, Syriac, Armenian, Ethiopian and Malankara churches accept three councils only, Nicaea, Constantinople and Ephesus, and do not receive Chalcedon (451).
They hold to Cyril's formula of "one nature of the Word of God Incarnate" and confess Christ truly God and truly man; Chalcedonian writers called them "Monophysites", while they describe themselves as Oriental Orthodox.
Receives seven councils, from Nicaea (325) to Nicaea II (787), holds the canons of the Council in Trullo at the same level of authority, and confesses the creed of 381 without "and the Son".
The Holy and Great Council of Crete (2016) names the council of 879 to 880 and the Palamite councils among the later councils of universal authority, and some Orthodox voices argue that they should be counted as the eighth and ninth. Vladimir Lossky, as Kallistos Ware quotes him, defined Tradition as "the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church", and Orthodox theologians differ on whether "development of doctrine" is the right name for change in its expression.
Counts twenty-one ecumenical councils, with Constantinople IV (869 to 870) as the eighth, and holds that a council is never ecumenical unless it is "confirmed or at least accepted as such by the successor of Peter".
The First Vatican Council holds that the sense of a dogma once declared is kept for ever while understanding of it grows, and John Paul II called the Catechism of 1992 "a sure norm for teaching the faith".
The Declaration of Utrecht (24 September 1889) adopts the Vincentian rule and the faith of the undivided Church of the first millennium.
It rejects the Vatican decrees of 1870 on papal infallibility and the universal episcopate and the 1854 dogma of the Immaculate Conception. At Bonn in 1875 Old Catholic, Orthodox and Anglican theologians judged the insertion of "and the Son" irregular and agreed that the Spirit proceeds from the Father through the Son.
Receive the doctrine of the early councils as Scriptural without listing the councils, and confess the three ecumenical creeds and the Book of Concord (1580).
The Formula of Concord makes the Scriptures alone the "only rule and norm" and the symbols "only a testimony and declaration of the faith". The Lutheran Church Missouri Synod subscribes the Confessions because they agree with the Bible, not merely in so far as they do, while the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America accepts the Augsburg Confession "as a true witness to the Gospel" and the other books as further valid interpretations.
Calvin and the Second Helvetic Confession receive the first four councils, Nicaea, Constantinople, Ephesus and Chalcedon, as agreeing with Scripture.
The Westminster Confession (1647) names "the Holy Spirit speaking in the Scripture" as supreme judge and holds that all synods and councils "may err; and many have erred". Reformed churches hold their confessions in different collections, from the Three Forms of Unity to the Book of Confessions of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.).
Article 21 of the Articles of Religion holds that general councils "may err and sometime have erred", and Article 8 receives the Nicene, Athanasian and Apostles' Creeds because they may be proved from Scripture.
The Bethel Agreed Statement of 2022 records among Anglicans a broad consensus in favor of the first four councils and a respect for six and sometimes seven, with no number officially set. The Church of England bears witness to the faith in its historic formularies, the Thirty-nine Articles, the Book of Common Prayer and the Ordinal.
Adolf von Harnack read dogma "in its conception and development" as "a work of the Greek spirit on the soil of the Gospel", a construction which historical criticism can separate from the Gospel.
On this account development is a matter for critical history rather than for confidence in continuity.
From the Schleitheim Confession (1527) to the Mennonite Confession of Faith of 1995 the same positions recur: believers' baptism, the ban, separation from the world, and refusal of the oath and of the sword.
The Amish affirm the eighteen articles of the Dordrecht Confession (1632), and the Hutterites hold the confession of Peter Riedemann.
Describe their documents as confessions rather than creeds: the 1925 statement, kept in the 2000 report, calls them "only guides in interpretation, having no authority over the conscience", while the 2000 preamble calls them "instruments of doctrinal accountability".
The Second London Confession (1677, endorsed 1689) became the standard of Calvinistic Baptists, and the Southern Baptist Convention holds the Baptist Faith and Message of 2000, amended in 2023.
Hold the Articles of Religion, Wesley's abridgment of the Thirty-nine Articles adopted at the Christmas Conference of 1784, with the General Rules and Wesley's Sermons and Notes.
In the United Methodist Church the First Restrictive Rule forbids the General Conference to "revoke, alter, or change our Articles of Religion", and the Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren stands beside them.
The Assemblies of God (USA) adopted its Statement of Fundamental Truths in 1916; the original preamble called it "not intended as a creed for the Church", while the current text calls it "a basis of fellowship among us".
Oneness Pentecostals deny the Trinity: the United Pentecostal Church International confesses one God who has revealed himself as Father, through his Son in redemption, and as the Holy Spirit by emanation.
Accepts the Bible as its only creed while holding 28 Fundamental Beliefs, which a General Conference Session may revise.
Of the historical statements only the 1980 text of 27 beliefs was voted by a Session; the 2005 Session added a 28th, and the 2015 Session revised the wording.
Thomas Campbell's Declaration and Address (1809) holds that "nothing ought to be inculcated upon Christians as articles of faith" unless Scripture expressly teaches it, and early Disciples, following Alexander Campbell, rejected creeds as tests of fellowship.
The Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) confesses Jesus as the Christ in the Preamble to its Design, which it says is not a "test of fellowship", while the Churches of Christ have no central body whose own statement can be cited.
Arose in mid-seventeenth-century England "without creeds, clergy, or other ecclesiastical forms", in Britannica's words.
Friends state belief in texts of their own, from Barclay's fifteen Theological Theses (1675) and the Richmond Declaration of Faith (1887) to the yearly meetings' books of discipline, and Britain Yearly Meeting explains the objection to creeds as a refusal of enforced conformity.
State belief through the publications of the Governing Body rather than through a creed.
They hold that there is "no Scriptural basis for the Trinity doctrine" and that Jesus "is not Almighty God".
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints does not accept "the creeds, confessions, and formulations of post-New Testament Christianity", and teaches that "the members of the Godhead are three separate beings".
Doctrine resides in the standard works, official declarations and the Articles of Faith; the Community of Christ, which descends from the same church of 1830, affirms the Trinity.
The First Council of Constantinople, summoned by Gratian and Theodosius I, confirms the Nicene faith and anathematizes the Pneumatomachi; the question of the Holy Spirit is what most clearly distinguishes it from 325. The creed now associated with it is first named as "the faith of the 150 fathers" at Chalcedon in 451.828384
The Council of Chalcedon confesses one Christ "in two natures, unconfusedly, immutably, indivisibly, inseparably", weaving parts of Leo's Tome into its definition. Many in Palestine, Syria, Armenia and Egypt refuse the definition, and the churches now called Oriental Orthodox accept three councils only.8586875
The Second Council of Nicaea, convened by the Empress Irene, distinguishes the "salutation and respectful veneration" given to images from the full adoration that belongs to the divine nature alone. The Frankish Synod of Frankfurt (794) rejects the council, whose decrees are gradually accepted in the West in later centuries.919293
Papal legates lay a bull of excommunication against Patriarch Michael Cerularius on the altar of Hagia Sophia, citing among his errors the omission of the Filioque from the creed. Paul VI and Athenagoras I commit the sentences to oblivion on 7 December 1965, an act that does not of itself restore communion.95969798
The Council of Florence's decree of union with the Greeks, Laetentur caeli, brings together the procession of the Spirit from Father and Son "as from one principle", purgatory and Roman primacy, and Mark of Ephesus alone of the Orthodox delegation refuses to sign. A synod at Constantinople under Patriarch Symeon denounces the council in 1484.101102103
The Synod of Jerusalem, convened by Patriarch Dositheus, answers the Confession of Cyril Lucaris in eighteen decrees, teaching seven sacraments and using the term "transubstantiated" for the Eucharistic change. With Peter Mogila's Orthodox Confession, approved by a synod of the Ecumenical Patriarchate on 11 March 1643, it is held among the Orthodox symbolic books with what Heith-Stade calls "a certain ambivalence".110111112113
The Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church confirm the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification at Augsburg, which states a consensus in basic truths of justification. The World Methodist Council associates itself with it in 2006 and the World Communion of Reformed Churches in 2017, while the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod stands apart.118119120121
Read the texts themselves first: council decrees and canons, and the creeds and confessions in collections such as Schaff's Creeds of Christendom and the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, with reference works and secondary studies after them126127.
Fix for each text its date, place, authors, occasion and issuing body; where the sources give different dates, give both with their sources.
Tell the kinds of text apart: a creed is a brief affirmation for worship or initiation, a confession a longer systematic declaration, and a catechism a manual of instruction128129.
Describe each church from its own councils, confessions and official texts and in its own terms, not by labels that others have applied to it84.
Say whose count of councils is followed, since each family's count follows its own history15.
Keep apart whether a church affirms a doctrine and whether it formally receives the council or text that defined it.
Record silence in a church's texts as silence, never as denial.
Record how each church received an agreed statement: the statements of the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox Joint Commission, for example, are agreements of the commission, not acts of the churches130131.
The works below shaped the field and are cited in this study, from the earliest to the most recent. Hover over a book, or select it, to see its author and the sources behind it.
Listed because this study draws on their published work; no association with or endorsement of Numa Verse is implied. Suggest a correction.
The words that carry the most weight in this field, each defined from the sources of this study. Turn a card over to read its definition.
It depends on the church: the Church of the East receives two councils, the Oriental Orthodox three, the Eastern Orthodox seven and the Catholic Church twenty-one15918. Lutherans, Reformed and Anglicans receive the early councils as agreeing with Scripture, the Reformed texts naming four and Anglicans showing a broad consensus on four and a respect for six and sometimes seven315.
No: the story that each apostle contributed a clause is first set out by Rufinus, and Thurston, in the Catholic Encyclopedia of 1907, calls his account unhistorical140165. The creed grew from the Old Roman Creed, attested in Greek by about 341, and its received text is first attested in full in the eighth century, in the work of Pirminius139166. At the Council of Florence in 1438 Mark of Ephesus said "we neither have nor know a creed of the apostles"167.
The creed of 381 says that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father; the words "and the Son" first appear in Spain and were inserted into the Latin creed in 10148994. The Orthodox Church in America calls the addition "a doctrinal addition unacceptable to Orthodoxy", and the objection runs on two lines: it was made without an ecumenical council, and it obscures the Father as sole source16890. The Catholic Church keeps the clause in the Latin creed while the Greek text of 381 remains the normative form, and its Catechism calls the two formulas a "legitimate complementarity"169170.
No: early Disciples rejected creeds as tests of fellowship, the Friends arose without creeds, and Baptists call their statements confessions, "only guides in interpretation"636645. Non-creedal does not mean without authoritative teaching, since each such church states its belief in texts of its own6965. Jehovah's Witnesses and Latter-day Saints state their belief through their own teaching and reject the historic creeds7273.
The churches answer differently. Vincent of Lérins allowed progress "in the same doctrine, in the same sense, and in the same meaning" but not alteration, and Newman proposed seven notes of genuine development171114. The First Vatican Council holds that the sense of a dogma once declared is kept for ever while understanding of it grows, Lutheran and Reformed confessions place every later formulation under Scripture, and Orthodox writers speak of the one faith newly expressed in the life of the Church202733123.
Reviewed and approved by Duane Herholdt, BA (Theology), Chief Executive Officer, Numa Verse
Study version: v1.1, 30 October 2026 (theology map v1.27)
Last reviewed: 9 November 2026