Why it matters for reading Scripture
Care for people in need is an ancient Christian practice that now draws on psychology and contests it. Church guidance and professional codes share two rules: know your limits, and route anyone in danger to help.
Practical theologyHow is it lived and shared?
Pastoral care and counseling is the Christian care of people in grief, guilt, doubt, suffering, abuse, illness and crisis, and the question of where that care ends and other help begins. Pastoral care is the whole church's care for people; pastoral counseling is a structured conversation led by a trained minister; pastoral therapy is specialized and long term.
Study v1.1, 7 November 2026
Care for people in need is an ancient Christian practice that now draws on psychology and contests it. Church guidance and professional codes share two rules: know your limits, and route anyone in danger to help.
Christian care of souls is ancient and varied; modern pastoral care draws on psychology and contests it. Church guidance and professional codes share two rules: know your limits; route anyone in danger to help.
Christians divide on how Scripture relates to psychology, spiritual and medical accounts of distress, deliverance, what healing to expect, divorce and remarriage, and counsel on sexuality.
Stands in the line of Anton Boisen, Seward Hiltner and Clinebell and integrates theology with psychology.
Clinebell's Basic Types of Pastoral Counseling (1966) was revised in 1984 toward "a more holistic and explicitly liberation-growth paradigm", and its third edition (2011) still teaches "holistic, growth-oriented pastoral care and counseling in the parish".
Treats psychology and theology as separate disciplines giving complementary perspectives.
Eric Johnson's Psychology and Christianity: Five Views gives David Myers as its holder.
Holds that Scripture governs core belief and that psychological findings are integrated with it; Stanton Jones is its holder in the Five Views volume.
Rosemead School of Psychology at Biola joins research with "biblical perspectives on human flourishing" in APA-accredited doctoral programs.
In the view of Robert Roberts and Paul Watson, builds an explicitly Christian psychology from the church's own tradition rather than integrating a secular one.
Held by John Coe and Todd Hall, one of the five positions on psychology and faith that Johnson's Five Views volume sets out within evangelicalism.
Holds, in the words of the Association of Certified Biblical Counselors (ACBC), that "the Bible sufficiently informs the structure and content of counseling relationships" and that the church is "the primary context for soul care".
Jay Adams became its central figure with Competent to Counsel in 1970 and coined "nouthetic" from Paul's word nouthesia. Adams's original nouthetic approach, today's Christian Counseling and Educational Foundation (CCEF), which recognizes "the legitimate place of broader resources within the body of Christ", and ACBC are distinct positions. David Powlison's position is that Christian faith "is a psychology".
Emmanuel Lartey's intercultural approach starts from the claim that care must respect the diversity in which the world is made and that care often comes from unexpected sources, not only from religious officials.
Liberative care asks what oppresses the person, and African American pastoral theologians argue that the shepherding model centers the pastor, is individualistic and psychologically biased, and leaves oppressive structures unchallenged.
Masamba ma Mpolo of Congo grounded African pastoral counseling in the principle "I am, because we are" and argued in 1988 for "spirituality and counselling for liberation", in which illness is tied to broken relationships.
Daniël Louw reads ubuntu as "I am because we are" and calls for intercultural care built on hospitality and interpathy. Magezi records three emerging African responses: prophetic rituals, healing and deliverance, and communal support through family and group programs.
Permits a major exorcism only by a bishop or a priest with "special and express permission", after thorough medical and psychological or psychiatric testing, and only with "moral certitude" that possession is genuine.
The Catechism holds that a ratified and consummated marriage "cannot be dissolved by any human power", and that "We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives".
Its House of Bishops' guidelines of 1975 (revised 2012) require authorized ministers working in consultation with doctors, psychologists and psychiatrists, and say that deliverance ministry "should never be undertaken by one person ministering alone".
Its current guidance forbids deliverance aimed at changing a person's sexual orientation or gender identity, and its guidance on domestic abuse forbids mediation or relationship counseling where abuse is suspected.
Centers care on the spiritual father and the elder, whom Kallistos Ware describes as companion and guide.
A 2026 article from the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of Australia distinguishes the elder's charismatic guidance from the priest's absolution and states the limits: obedience never extends to sin, and guidance that breeds "fear, secrecy, or dependence" is not true fatherhood. Orthodox teaching calls confession "an ecclesial ministry, not a private charisma detached from the bishop", in which the confessor acts as a physician.
Holds that "Deliverance from sickness is provided for in the Atonement", that divine healing "neither opposes nor competes with medical doctors", and that "some are healed instantly, some gradually, and others are not healed".
Affirms expectant faith in God's power but denies that it is "automatic" and that illness, poverty or early death always shows a curse or a lack of faith.
Allows divorce only for "adultery, or such willful desertion as can no way be remedied by the church, or civil magistrate".
Supports protection from coercive and abusive practices but argues that the draft Conversion Practices Bill of June 2026 could put at legal risk adults who freely seek prayer or pastoral support.
The UK Memorandum of Understanding, signed by 29 bodies, holds that conversion therapy "is unethical, potentially harmful and is not supported by evidence".
The American Psychological Association opposes sexual orientation change efforts, while noting that approaches which reduce distress from conflict between orientation and religion without harm "show promise".
Luther writes to his friend Jerome Weller, who is struggling with despair: "By all means flee solitude". His letters of spiritual counsel show him as a pastor in sickness, death and despair.30
Martin Bucer's Concerning the True Care of Souls sets out five tasks: to lead the estranged to Christ, to restore those who have drifted, to help the fallen to amend, to strengthen the weak, and to protect and encourage the steady. Its ideas were applied in the Strasbourg congregation Calvin pastored from 1538 to 1541.31
William Perkins's Whole Treatise of the Cases of Conscience is printed at Cambridge from his lectures, an example of the Puritan casuistry that answered cases of conscience.32
Richard Baxter's The Reformed Pastor, first titled Gildas Salvianus, expounds Acts 20:28 and begins with "The Oversight of Ourselves". Baxter met every family in his parish by appointment, "about fifteen or sixteen families in a week".33
Anton Boisen, himself hospitalized for mental illness from 1920, runs the first clinical training unit in the summer with four students, reading "the living human documents" alongside books.1
Seward Hiltner's Preface to Pastoral Theology gives the field its shepherding perspective and defines pastoral theology as "a formal branch of theology resulting from the study of Christian shepherding".2
Clebsch and Jaekle define pastoral care as "helping acts, done by representative Christian persons, directed toward the healing, sustaining, guiding, and reconciling of troubled persons", still the standard reference point.34
E. Brooks Holifield's A History of Pastoral Care in America traces American pastoral care from saving souls to supporting self-realization.37
Thomas Oden's Care of Souls in the Classic Tradition critiques contemporary pastoral counseling while still valuing clinical psychotherapy. Oden wrote that pastoral care had been "steadily accommodated to a series of psychotherapies" and had fallen into "a state of amnesia" about its classical past.3834
Masamba ma Mpolo of Congo argues for "spirituality and counselling for liberation": life is an integrated whole, illness is tied to broken relationships, and counseling should pursue critical awareness, not only comfort.13
In South Africa, the Association for Clinical Pastoral Work, the Association for Pastoral Psychology and the Association for Clinical Pastoral Education in Southern Africa combine to form the Southern African Association for Pastoral Work (SAAP).39
Six North American chaplaincy and pastoral counseling bodies affirm a Common Code of Ethics, which requires carers to "Understand the limits of their individual expertise and make referrals to other professionals when appropriate".40
The American Association of Pastoral Counselors, founded in the 1960s to set standards for pastoral counselors, joins ACPE as an integrated organization. In September South Africa's Minister of Health confirms that the 2008 regulations reserving "psychological counselling" and "any psychotherapeutic method" to the profession of psychology "remain in force".414243
Illinois bars AI "therapeutic decision-making" in August 2025, and the American Psychological Association warns in November 2025 that "Relying solely on an app during a mental health emergency can be dangerous". California's SB 243, in force from 1 January 2026, requires companion chatbots to run a protocol for suicidal ideation that notifies users of crisis service providers.444546
Read the person as well as the books: Boisen trained students to read "the living human documents"1.
Give each hearer the words that suit them, because "one and the same exhortation does not suit all"48.
Keep in view the aims Clebsch and Jaekle name: the healing, sustaining, guiding and reconciling of troubled persons34.
Where suicide may be in question, ask directly, do not promise secrecy, be there, help keep the person safe, help the person connect to crisis lines and professionals, and follow up49.
In life-threatening danger, the person calls emergency services50.
Where abuse is suspected, put safety first: no mediation or relationship counseling, and no pressure to leave, disclose, reconcile or forgive, because that can increase risk21.
Speak of suicide by safe-messaging guidance: no method or location, no presenting suicide as a solution, never "committed suicide", and always a route to help51.
Keep confidences within their limits: disclosure may be "for the safety of any person" or "when required by law"40.
Know the limits of one's own expertise and refer to other professionals when appropriate40.
The works below shaped the field and are cited in this study, from the earliest to the most recent. Hover over a book, or select it, to see its author and the sources behind it.
Listed because this study draws on their published work; no association with or endorsement of Numa Verse is implied. Suggest a correction.
The words that carry the most weight in this field, each defined from the sources of this study. Turn a card over to read its definition.
Pastoral care is the whole church's care for people; pastoral counseling is a structured conversation led by a trained minister; pastoral therapy or psychotherapy is specialized and long term3915. South African practical theology adds a fourth form, mutual care, in which the whole community of believers supports its members15.
No: asking about suicide does not increase suicides or suicidal thoughts, and the World Health Organization states that "suicides can be prevented"4953. The #BeThe1To steps of the 988 Lifeline are to ask directly, not to promise secrecy, to be there, to help keep the person safe, to help the person connect to crisis lines and professionals, and to follow up49.
The record is mixed, and research in particular communities should not be generalized to all churches. In a Baylor study of 293 Christians who sought church help for a diagnosed mental illness in themselves or a family member, more than 32 percent were told by their church that they did not really have a mental illness47. A 2014 Lifeway survey found that 49 percent of Protestant pastors rarely or never speak about mental illness, while 59 percent of people with mental illness want their church to talk about it openly59.
The research is early and mixed6061. The American Psychological Association says such tools should not replace a qualified provider and that "Relying solely on an app during a mental health emergency can be dangerous"45. A Stanford study found stigma in therapy chatbots, a RAND study found general chatbots inconsistent on suicide questions at intermediate risk, and Illinois has barred AI "therapeutic decision-making"626344.
Not always. The Common Code of Ethics of six North American chaplaincy and pastoral counseling bodies protects information except where disclosure is "required for necessary treatment", "granted by client permission", "for the safety of any person" or "when required by law"40. In South Africa, Smit v Van Niekerk (1976) held that "the law does not recognise the clergy privilege", and every adult must report domestic violence against a child, a person with a disability or an older person6465. In the United States, clergy reporting duties and privilege vary by state66.
Reviewed and approved by Duane Herholdt, BA (Theology), Chief Executive Officer, Numa Verse
Study version: v1.1, 7 November 2026 (theology map v1.27)
Last reviewed: 9 November 2026